Tax Deductions for Scam and Theft Losses

Understanding the nuances of tax deductions for scam and theft losses is critical, particularly given recent legislative adjustments that mostly restrict casualty and theft deductions to federally declared disasters. Nevertheless, victims of scams can still explore certain tax options.

Historically, the tax code allowed for deductions of theft losses not covered by insurance. Despite recent law changes restricting these deductions primarily to disaster-linked events, there remains a notable avenue for scam victims. Specifically, if you incurred losses while pursuing a profit-oriented transaction, deductions remain accessible. Image 1

Under Internal Revenue Code Section 165(c)(2), losses tied to profit-driven activities are specifically addressed. This provision allows scam victims to claim deductions without a disaster declaration if their losses are linked to profit-seeking transactions. This critical exemption provides a possible financial lifeline for recovering from scams.

Criteria for Profit-Driven Casualty Losses: To qualify for this exception, certain conditions must be met:

  1. Profit Motive: The IRS requires clear intent for economic gain, substantiated with substantial documentation, to validate the transaction as profit-oriented.
  2. Type of Transaction: Only genuine investment activities like securities or real estate ventures typically qualify. Casual or personal activities generally do not.
  3. Nature of Loss: Losses must result directly from the profit-driven transaction, with evidence to support this through financial and legal records.

IRS Guidance Application: OSHA guidance and memoranda are essential for understanding deductible loss scenarios. IRC memoranda, like CCM 202511015, clarify situations where deduction eligibility applies, particularly involving:

  • Investment Scams: Transactions initially made with legitimate profit expectations can be deductible. Documentation such as communications, contracts, and transfer records is key.
  • Profit-Motive Theft: Scrutiny is high for these cases. Losses must be incurred during a profit-purposed transaction, not through personal exchanges.

Impactful Tax Ramifications: Scams affecting IRAs or pension funds impact taxes significantly, contingent upon account type and withdrawal circumstances.

For traditional IRAs, premature withdrawals due to scams are taxable, potentially increasing your tax bracket. A 10% penalty may apply if under 59½. In contrast, Roth account withdrawals might be less severe, given prior taxed contributions, provided conditions are met.

The following examples illustrate the eligibility or ineligibility for losses:

Example 1: Investment Scam - Eligible Casualty Loss

An investor's funds were fraudulently transferred into scammer-controlled accounts, with motives to reinvest securely, meeting the profit-centric conditions for deductibility.

Tax Implications:
a. Deductible if itemizing on Schedule A.
b. IRA disbursements are taxable; non-IRA requires gain/loss recognition.
c. Possible IRA rollovers within 60 days to mitigate.

Image 2

Example 2: Romance Scam - Non-Qualifying Loss

A taxpayer transferred money overseas due to personal reasons under a ruse, failing to meet profit-motive criteria, rendering losses non-deductible.

Tax Implications: No deduction allowed; standard tax implications on distributions as indicated in Example 1.

These scenarios underscore the importance of properly documenting intent and transaction nature to determine deductibility. Strengthened scrutiny and updated IRS guidelines necessitate precise adherence for qualifying deductions. Consult our Houston-based firm for guidance, and encourage proactive measures to prevent scam losses within your network. We are committed to delivering strategic tax planning and resolution services.

Share this article...

Want our best tax and accounting tips and insights delivered to your inbox?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Let us take your tax and accounting needs off your hands today.